CO-P4 Denial Code (CARC P4) 2026: Comp Claim Adjudicated as Non-Compensable

The CO-P4 denial code means the workers’ compensation carrier ruled the whole injury claim non-compensable, so it is not liable for any treatment on it. The decision is about the comp case itself, not your coding. While the worker disputes it, you can usually bill the patient’s health plan with the carrier’s denial attached. (Primary source: X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes)

Need to appeal a CO-P4 denial?Generate an appeal letter in 60 seconds. Free, pre-filled for CO-P4.
Generate appeal letter for CO-P4

In brief: reason code P4 closes the comp door for now. Get the carrier’s written decision, ask the patient whether a dispute is filed, and send the claim to the health plan with proof of the comp denial. If the comp claim is later accepted, the carrier pays and the plan takes its money back.

Part of our denial codes library. Written by Manikandan J, CPC, CRCR, who has worked disputed workers’ comp accounts for hand surgery, occupational medicine and hospital outpatient teams. Published 21 November 2026. Last updated: 21 November 2026. Code wording quoted word for word from X12. Read about the author and our editorial policy, or contact us to report an error.

What does denial code CO-P4 mean?

Denial code CO-P4 says the comp carrier finished its review and decided the claim is not covered by workers’ compensation. Common reasons include late notice to the employer, a finding that the condition did not arise from the job, or a dispute over whether the person was an employee. Only workers’ comp carriers send it.

FieldValue
CodeP4
Description“Workers’ Compensation claim adjudicated as non-compensable. This Payer not liable for claim or service/treatment.”
Who may use itWorkers’ Compensation only
Group codesNo X12 group restriction; CO is the usual pairing
Start11/01/2013 (last modified 07/01/2017); replaces code 214
Common remarksN437, N607

Source: X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes, checked 21 November 2026.

Methodology: the code wording is copied from the X12 list, and the payer order rules come from the CMS guide and manual cited below.

Key terms: A non-compensable claim is a comp claim the carrier has denied as a whole. A conditional payment is a payment another payer makes while the comp dispute is open, subject to later recovery. The first report of injury is the employer’s notice that starts the comp claim.

CO-P4 or OA-P4: which one did you get?

GroupWho carries the amountWhat to do
CO-P4Not the comp carrier; your office must route it to the next payer before any write-offBill the health plan with the comp denial
OA-P4No one is named; the carrier is only reporting it is not liableSame routing; watch the dispute outcome

How is CO-P4 different from CO-P2?

CARC P2 says one condition or injury is not work related. CARC P4 is broader: the carrier has denied the entire comp claim. With P4, every date of service on that claim number is affected, and the remark N437 often signals that the carrier will look again if the injury claim is accepted later.

Example scenario (fictional names), part 1

CO-P4 Denial Example: What Happened

Lena Marsh, the biller at Copperfield Hand Center, opened a remit for a line cook with right carpal tunnel syndrome, G56.01. Dr. Rafael Ibarra had billed 99214 and an injection, 20526, to a fictional comp carrier.

The 835 showed CAS*CO*P4 with remark code N437, “Alert: If the injury claim is accepted, these charges will be reconsidered.” The carrier’s letter said the claim was non-compensable after an independent exam. The patient said her lawyer had filed an appeal with the state board. Registration had also scanned her group health plan card.

With the dispute open, does the practice just wait? Keep reading, or jump to how the CO-P4 denial was resolved.

Who pays while the comp claim is disputed?

The CMS WCMSA Reference Guide says that if responsibility for the comp claim is in dispute and comp will not pay promptly, the provider may bill Medicare as primary. Medicare may pay conditionally, subject to later recovery. Many group health plans follow a similar path when you send the comp denial.

Patient’s coverageWhat to send
Group health planNew claim with the comp denial letter or remit attached
MedicareClaim to Medicare; it may pay conditionally
MedicaidClaim to Medicaid with the comp denial
No coverageHold the account until the dispute ends, then follow your self-pay policy

How do I fix a CO-P4 denial?

To fix a CO-P4 denial, do not rewrite the comp claim. Route the bill to the next payer and keep the work-injury flags, because the injury is still claimed as work related.

Routing steps for a non-compensable claim: get the decision, check the dispute, bill the plan
StepWhat to doProof
1Get the carrier’s written decision and the claim numberDenial letter or 835
2Ask the patient or attorney whether a dispute is filedHearing or appeal notice
3Send a new claim to the health plan with the denial attachedBox 19 or the 837 attachment segment
4If the comp claim is later accepted, rebill the carrier and refund the planThe board’s order

The CMS Medicare Secondary Payer Manual, Chapter 3 lists condition code 02 and occurrence code 04 for employment-related care. Keep them on the facility claim so the plan sees the comp history.

Example scenario (fictional names), part 2

How the CO-P4 Denial Was Resolved

Lena kept the comp account open as disputed and set a reminder for the hearing date. Then she switched payers.

Fix: a new claim went to the patient’s group health plan. Box 11 named the plan, Box 10a stayed yes, and Box 19 noted the attached comp denial. 99214, 20526 and G56.01 did not change. She attached the carrier’s letter and the remit page with the P4 line.

Outcome: the plan paid under its normal benefits. Months later the board upheld the carrier, so the plan’s payment stood. Lena now asks every comp patient for an attorney contact at the first visit.

Names and details are illustrative; no real patient data.

Names and details are illustrative; no real patient data.

CO-P4 CMS-1500 claim form moving Box 11 to the health plan, with Box 19 noting the comp denial
Example (fictional data): Box 11 names the plan; Box 19 notes the comp denial.
CO-P4 UB-04 claim form with FL 50 naming the health plan and FL 80 remarks citing the comp denial
Example (fictional data): FL 50 names the plan; FL 80 cites the comp denial.
  • Box 1 / Box 11 / Box 11c: the payer changed from the comp carrier to the patient’s group health plan. It is a new claim to that payer, so Box 22 stays blank.
  • Box 19: notes that the carrier’s non-compensable decision is attached.
  • Box 10a: stays yes, because the injury is still claimed as work related while the dispute is open.
  • Box 21 / Box 24D: G56.01 (entered as G5601), 99214 and 20526-RT are unchanged.
  • UB-04 FL 50 / FL 80: payer line A now names the health plan, and the remarks cite the attached comp denial; condition code 02 and occurrence code 04 stay.

Can I bill the patient for a CO-P4 denial?

Not first. Send the claim to the patient’s health plan or Medicare, which may pay while the dispute is open. If the patient has no coverage, many states limit billing while a comp claim is in litigation, so check your state’s rules before sending a statement.

How do I prevent CO-P4 surprises?

You cannot stop a carrier from denying a claim, but you can avoid unpaid months. For example, verify the comp claim is accepted before scheduling elective treatment, such as surgery or injections. Collect the health plan card at the first comp visit too. The NUCC 1500 instructions explain Box 10a and Box 19.

CodeMeaning
CO-P2Not a work-related injury or illness; not the comp carrier’s liability
CO-19Work-related injury; the liability of the workers’ comp carrier
CO-P1State-mandated requirement for property and casualty
CO-22Care may be covered by another payer under coordination of benefits

FAQ

What does CO-P4 mean?

The workers’ comp carrier denied the whole claim as non-compensable, so it will not pay for any treatment on it.

Who pays while a CARC P4 is disputed?

The patient’s health plan or Medicare may pay, often conditionally, when you send the comp denial with the claim.

What does N437 mean with CO-P4?

It is an alert that the carrier will reconsider the charges if the injury claim is accepted later.

Should I change Box 10a after a CO-P4?

No. The injury is still claimed as work related. Keep Box 10a as yes and attach the comp denial instead.

Which group code comes with CARC P4?

X12 sets no group restriction. CO is the most common pairing, and OA also appears.

Sources

How we checked: the CARC P4 quote was matched word for word with the X12 CARC list on 21 November 2026, and N437 and N607 with the X12 RARC list.

Last updated: 21 November 2026 · Educational content; not legal advice.