Claim Denied as “Not Medically Necessary”? How to Appeal and Get an External Review

Last updated: By Manikandan JFact-checked by Manikandan J, CPC, CRCR, 10+ years in US RCM · Editorial policy

You can fight a “not medically necessary” denial, and you have more time and more rights than most people think. Ask your insurer for the claim file and the clinical criteria it used, file a written internal appeal within 180 days, and get your doctor to send a letter that answers those criteria point by point. If the plan still says no, ask for an independent external review. Its decision binds the insurer.

A medical necessity denial means the insurer agrees the service is something your plan can cover, but decided it wasn’t needed for your condition, or not at that level of care. That’s different from a service your plan never covers at all. The difference matters, because only medical-judgment denials qualify for external review.

Key takeaways

  • Employer and Marketplace plans must give you at least 180 days from the denial notice to file an internal appeal (29 CFR 2560.503-1).
  • You can get the claim file, the guideline the insurer relied on, and the reason behind its clinical judgment free of charge.
  • External review covers denials based on medical judgment, including medical necessity. You generally have 4 months to ask for it, and the insurer must follow the reviewer’s decision.
  • Few people appeal. KFF found that HealthCare.gov enrollees appealed fewer than 1% of denied in-network claims in 2024 (KFF, March 2026).

How this guide was checked: the deadlines and rights below come from the federal regulations and the HealthCare.gov and KFF pages linked where they’re used. This is educational content, not legal or medical advice.

Table of Contents

What “not medically necessary” means on your EOB

Your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) usually shows a short reason. Behind it, the claim carries a standard Claim Adjustment Reason Code (CARC) that the billing office sees on the insurer’s electronic remittance. The wording comes from the X12 code list. A remark code is a second code that adds detail to the reason. These are the codes that matter here:

Code on the remittanceOfficial X12 wording (short)What it usually means for you
CO-50“These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a ‘medical necessity’ by the payer.”A medical-judgment denial. Appeal it, and external review is available
CO-197“Precertification/authorization/notification/pre-treatment absent.”No prior approval was on file. Often fixable by the provider first
CO-96“Non-covered charge(s).”Often a plan exclusion. Read the remark code before you appeal
CO-167“This (these) diagnosis(es) is (are) not covered.”The diagnosis code didn’t match the insurer’s policy. Sometimes a coding issue

The group code in front matters too. CO (contractual obligation) means the provider usually can’t bill you for that amount if it’s in network. PR (patient responsibility) means the insurer says you owe it. Our CO-50 denial code page and the full denial code list explain each code from the billing side.

Medical necessity vs exclusion: a quick test

Ask yourself one question: does the denial say the plan doesn’t cover this service at all, or that it wasn’t needed for you?

  • “Not covered under your plan,” “excluded benefit,” or “contract exclusion” points to an exclusion. You can still file an internal appeal, but you’d have to show the plan applied its terms wrongly.
  • “Not medically necessary,” “does not meet clinical criteria,” “experimental or investigational,” or “level of care not appropriate” points to a medical-judgment denial. These are the denials external review was built for.

KFF’s 2024 Marketplace data shows that most in-network denials aren’t labeled as medical necessity at all. Insurers listed “other” reasons for 36%, administrative reasons for 25%, excluded services for 13%, prior authorization or referral for 9% and medical necessity for 5% (KFF, March 2026). So read the exact reason before you plan your appeal.

For example, a plan that never covers cosmetic surgery has an exclusion. A plan that covers MRIs but says yours wasn’t needed made a medical-judgment call.

Step-by-step: how to appeal a medical necessity denial

  1. Write down your deadline. The denial letter must tell you how to appeal. For employer and Marketplace plans, you get at least 180 days from the notice. Medicare and Medicare Advantage have their own, shorter clocks (see the table below).
  2. Call your doctor’s billing office first. Ask what codes they billed and whether the denial came with a request for records. If the problem was a missing record or a coding error, the office can often send records or a corrected claim faster than an appeal. Billers usually see this as CO-50 or CO-167 with a remark code.
  3. Request the claim file and the criteria in writing. Use the template below. Federal rules say you can get, free of charge, all documents relevant to your claim, any internal rule or guideline the insurer relied on, and an explanation of the clinical judgment behind the denial.
  4. Ask your doctor for a letter of medical necessity. It should answer the insurer’s criteria one by one: your diagnosis, what you already tried, why other options won’t work and what could happen without the service. Our guide on medical necessity records payers look for shows what reviewers check.
  5. Send a written appeal. Use the appeal letter template below. Attach the doctor’s letter, relevant records and the denial notice. Our free appeal letter generator can help you draft it. Keep copies and proof of sending.
  6. Ask for an expedited (urgent) appeal if waiting could hurt you. For urgent care, group plans must decide appeals within 72 hours. Your doctor can usually make this request for you.
  7. If the appeal is denied, request external review. You usually have 4 months from the final denial. If the plan didn’t follow the appeal rules strictly, the rules may let you go straight to external review.

Appeal deadlines by plan type

Plan typeTime to fileHow fast the plan must decide
Employer or Marketplace plan, internal appealAt least 180 days from the denial noticeUrgent: 72 hours. Pre-service: 30 days (one level). Post-service: 60 days (one level)
External review (non-grandfathered plans)At least 4 months after the final denialStandard: 45 days. Expedited: 72 hours
Traditional Medicare, redetermination120 days from receiving the noticeSet by Medicare’s rules for each level
Medicare Advantage, reconsideration60 days from receiving the decisionSet by Medicare Advantage rules

Sources: 29 CFR 2560.503-1, 45 CFR 147.136, 42 CFR 405.942 and 42 CFR 422.582. If a group plan uses two appeal levels, each pre-service level gets 15 days and each post-service level gets 30 days. Grandfathered plans and some other plan types may follow different external review rules, so check your plan documents.

Free template 1: request for your claim file and clinical criteria

Send this as soon as you get the denial. It costs nothing and often shows exactly what the reviewer wanted.

[Your name]
[Address] | [Phone] | [Member ID] | [Group number]
[Date]

[Insurer name] - Appeals / Member Services
[Address from your denial letter]

Re: Request for claim file and clinical criteria
Claim number: [ ]   Date of service: [ ]   Provider: [ ]

I got a denial dated [date] that says the service was not medically
needed. Under 29 CFR 2560.503-1 (or the matching rules for my plan),
please send me, free of charge:

1. All records and papers about this claim, including reviewer notes.
2. Any rule, guideline or clinical criteria you used to decide.
3. The clinical reason for the decision, based on my plan and my care.
4. The name and title of any doctor or nurse you asked.

This request does not replace my right to appeal. Please send the
papers to the address above.

Sincerely,
[Signature]

Free template 2: “not medically necessary” appeal letter

[Your name] | [Member ID] | [Group number] | [Phone]
[Date]

[Insurer name] - Appeals Department
[Address]

Re: Appeal of medical necessity denial
Claim/reference number: [ ]   Date of service: [ ]
Service denied: [name of test, procedure or drug]   Provider: [ ]

I am appealing your decision dated [date] that [service] was not
medically needed. Please have a new reviewer, who did not make the
first decision, look at it in full.

Why the service is medically necessary:
- My diagnosis: [condition, in plain words]
- Treatments already tried and the results: [list with dates]
- Why the denied service is needed now: [doctor's reasons]
- How my case meets your criteria: [quote each criterion from the
  guideline you received and the matching fact from my records]

Enclosed: the denial letter, my doctor's letter, and records [list].

[If urgent:] My doctor says waiting for a standard decision could
seriously harm my health. Please handle this as a fast appeal.

If you keep the denial, please tell me how to ask for an
independent external review.

Sincerely,
[Signature]

How external review works

External review sends your case to an Independent Review Organization (IRO), which has no stake in the outcome. HealthCare.gov says the insurer must accept the reviewer’s decision.

  • What qualifies: denials based on medical judgment, like medical necessity, appropriateness, health care setting, level of care or experimental treatment. A rescission of coverage also qualifies.
  • When to file: in writing, within 4 months of the final internal denial.
  • How fast: a decision within 45 days for standard review and 72 hours for expedited review.
  • Cost: the federal HHS process is free. Where an IRO or state process charges a fee, HealthCare.gov says it can’t be more than $25.
  • Who can file: you, or an authorized representative such as your doctor. An authorized representative is someone you name to act for you on the claim.

Your final denial letter should say whether your plan uses a state process or the federal one. For the federal HHS process, HealthCare.gov lists the toll-free line 1-888-866-6205. If you’re unsure which applies, ask your state’s Consumer Assistance Program, which HealthCare.gov also points to.

External review isn’t a long shot. KFF counted at least 5,881 external appeals by HealthCare.gov enrollees in 2024. Yet only 40% of consumers in a KFF survey believed they had external appeal rights at all (KFF, March 2026).

What the billing office can do for you

From the billing side, a medical necessity denial is often fixed before anyone writes a formal appeal:

  • Records request: if the insurer asked for records and never got them, the office can send them and ask for reprocessing.
  • Corrected claim: if a diagnosis code didn’t support the service (CO-167 or CO-50 with a policy remark), a coding fix may be legitimate. The provider must never change codes that don’t match your chart.
  • Peer-to-peer review: for planned care, your doctor may be able to talk to the insurer’s reviewer. See our guide to what to do when prior authorization is denied.
  • Prior auth denials: a missing authorization (CO-197) is a different problem. Here’s how billing teams handle CO-197 denials.

Ask the office to put the account on hold while the appeal is pending. That keeps the bill from moving toward collections. If a bill has already gone to an agency, see how to dispute a medical bill that went to collections.

FAQ

Do I have to pay the bill while my appeal is pending?

Not necessarily. If the denial shows the amount under group code CO and the provider is in network, the provider usually can’t bill you for it. If it’s under PR, ask the provider in writing to hold the balance until the appeal is decided.

Who should file the appeal, me or my doctor?

Either can, and doing it together works best. You can file it yourself, or name your doctor as your authorized representative. HealthCare.gov confirms a doctor can act for you in external review.

How long do I have to appeal?

Employer and Marketplace plans must give you at least 180 days after the denial notice. You then generally have 4 months after the final denial to request external review. Traditional Medicare allows 120 days and Medicare Advantage 60 days from when you receive the decision.

Is a “not medically necessary” denial the same as “not covered”?

No. “Not covered” usually means a plan exclusion. “Not medically necessary” means the insurer judged the care wasn’t needed for your condition. Only medical-judgment denials qualify for external review.

Does external review cost money?

The federal HHS process is free. HealthCare.gov says IROs or state processes that charge can’t charge more than $25.

Disclaimer: This article is educational and is not legal or medical advice. Appeal rights depend on your plan type (employer, Marketplace, Medicare, Medicaid or other), your state and the facts of your case. Check your denial letter and plan documents, and contact your state’s consumer assistance program or an attorney if you need advice about your situation. Rules can change, so check each linked source.

Written by Manikandan, RCM specialist at Medical Billing 101.

Sources

  1. eCFR, 29 CFR 2560.503-1, Claims procedure, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  2. eCFR, 45 CFR 147.136, Internal claims and appeals and external review processes, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  3. eCFR, 42 CFR 405.942 and 42 CFR 422.582, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  4. HealthCare.gov, External review, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  5. KFF, Claims Denials and Appeals in ACA Marketplace Plans in 2024, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  6. X12, Claim Adjustment Reason Codes, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.

Related denial codes

Browse all denial codes (CARC, RARC and group codes)

Manikandan J

Written by

Manikandan J

CPC (AAPC), CRCR (HFMA)

Manikandan J is a CPC (AAPC) and CRCR (HFMA) certified medical billing professional with billing and RCM experience at athenahealth, Omega Healthcare, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Access Healthcare. He writes Medical Billing 101's guides on denial codes, appeals and patient billing help for US billers, providers and insured patients.

10+ years in US revenue cycle management. How we fact-check · LinkedIn profile

More about the author →