Prior Authorization Denied? What to Do Next (MRI, Surgery or Medication)

Last updated: By Manikandan JFact-checked by Manikandan J, CPC, CRCR, 10+ years in US RCM · Editorial policy

When prior authorization is denied, don’t cancel your care yet. First, get the denial reason and reference number from your doctor’s office. Then ask if the office can resubmit with missing records. It may also ask for a peer-to-peer call with the insurer’s reviewer. If that fails, file an appeal. Ask for an expedited one if waiting could harm your health. Employer plans must decide urgent appeals within 72 hours.

Prior authorization is the insurer’s approval before certain care, like an MRI, a surgery or a specialty drug. You may also hear it called pre-authorization, pre-cert or “PA.” A PA denial is about care you haven’t had yet. So it counts as a “pre-service” claim, with its own faster deadlines.

Key takeaways

  • Most PA denials are handled by your doctor’s office first. You’re the backup and the record keeper.
  • Appeals work more often than you might think. In Medicare Advantage, KFF found 80.7% of appealed PA denials in 2024 were partly or fully overturned. Only 11.5% of denials were appealed (KFF, January 2026).
  • Since January 1, 2026, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP plans must decide standard requests within 7 calendar days. Expedited (fast) requests get 72 hours. A denial must give a clear reason.
  • Employer plans must decide urgent appeals within 72 hours and pre-service appeals within 30 days (one appeal level).

How this guide was checked: deadlines come from federal regulations and CMS’s prior authorization rule, and statistics come from KFF. This is educational content, not legal or medical advice.

Table of Contents

Why prior authorization gets denied

From the billing side, a PA denial most often falls into one of four groups. Knowing which one you have tells you who should act. For example, an MRI request may come back with “conservative treatment not tried” if the notes don’t show the therapy you had.

Denial typeWhat the letter often saysWho fixes it
Missing or incomplete records“Insufficient clinical information,” “lack of documentation”Doctor’s office resubmits
Doesn’t meet clinical criteria“Does not meet medical necessity criteria,” “conservative treatment not tried”Peer-to-peer, then appeal
Wrong service or site“Approved for a different code,” “outpatient setting appropriate”Office corrects the request
Not a covered benefit“Excluded under your plan”Appeal only if the plan applied its terms wrongly

Say the care happens with no approval. Then the claim often comes back with code CO-197, which means the approval was missing. Now say the approval covered fewer visits or units than were billed. Then you may see CO-198, which means the approval was used up. Both codes are on the X12 claim adjustment reason code list. Our prior auth checklist for billing teams shows what a full request has. This guide shows how billers work CO-197 denials. Other codes are in our denial code list.

Step-by-step: who to call, in what order

  1. Call your doctor’s office (the authorization or referral desk). Ask for the denial reason and the PA number. Ask for the decision date and the rules the reviewer used, too.
  2. Ask: “Can you resubmit, or is this a peer-to-peer?” If records were missing, a new full request is often faster than an appeal. If the reviewer disagreed on the facts, ask about a peer-to-peer call. A peer-to-peer review is a call between your doctor and the insurer’s reviewer. Many insurers set a short window for it, so ask right away.
  3. Call your insurer. Use the member number on your card. Ask for the denial letter, how to appeal and the appeal deadline. Write down the call reference number.
  4. Decide if it’s urgent. Could the normal wait put your life, health or recovery at serious risk? Then ask for an expedited (urgent) review. Expedited review is a fast track for urgent cases. Your doctor can back the request or make it.
  5. File a written appeal. Use the fast appeal letter below if it’s urgent. Add a letter from your doctor that says why you need the care. You can draft your own letter with our free appeal letter generator. Our guide on medical necessity records explains what reviewers look for.
  6. If the appeal fails, ask for external review. For denials based on medical judgment, an independent reviewer can overturn the insurer. See how external review works.
  7. Keep a log of every call. Use the free call log below. It’s your evidence if deadlines slip.

Decision deadlines by plan type

Plan typeFirst decision on a PA requestAppeal decision
Employer plan (ERISA)Urgent: 72 hours. Pre-service: 15 days, with one 15-day extensionUrgent: 72 hours. Pre-service: 30 days (one level)
Medicare AdvantageFrom 2026: 7 calendar days standard. Expedited: 72 hoursSet by Medicare Advantage appeal rules
Medicaid and CHIP (fee-for-service and managed care)From 2026: 7 calendar days standard, 72 hours expeditedSet by your state program

Sources: 29 CFR 2560.503-1, 42 CFR 422.568 and the CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization Final Rule (CMS-0057-F). CMS-0057-F’s 2026 decision timeframes don’t apply to drugs, and they don’t apply to Marketplace plans on the federal exchange. Medicare Advantage plans may extend a standard decision by up to 14 days in limited cases.

What “pended” and “partial approval” mean

  • Pended means the request is waiting on a nurse or doctor to review it, often because the insurer asked for more records. Ask the office what was requested and when it was sent. Under 29 CFR 2560.503-1, an employer plan that needs more facts must tell you what is missing.
  • Partial approval: the insurer approved fewer visits, units or days than your doctor asked for, or a different code. You can appeal the part that was not approved.
  • Approved with a different site: for example, an MRI approved at a freestanding center instead of a hospital. Ask if the approved site is in network before you book.

Free template 1: prior authorization call script and log

Call script

“Hi, I’m calling about a prior authorization for [service] for [patient name], date of birth [ ], member ID [ ]. Can you give me the status and the reference number? What was the reason, and when is the appeal due? Can you also tell me whether a peer-to-peer review is still available, and by what date?”

Call log: print it or copy it into a note. Fill in one row per call.

Date/timeWho I calledPerson’s nameReference #What they saidNext step / due date
      
      
      

Free template 2: expedited appeal letter

[Your name]
[Member ID] [Group number]
[Phone] [Email]
[Date]

[Insurer name] - Appeals (Expedited)
[Fax or address from the denial letter]

Re: EXPEDITED APPEAL - prior authorization denial
PA/reference number: [ ]   Date of denial: [ ]
Service requested: [MRI / surgery / drug name and code if known]
Requesting provider: [name, phone]

I am appealing the denied prior authorization for [service].
My doctor says waiting for a standard decision could put my
life, health or ability to regain full function at serious
risk, because [short reason from the doctor].

I ask that you:
1. Process this appeal on an expedited basis.
2. Have a clinician who did not make the first decision review it.
3. Send me the clinical rules used for the first denial.

Enclosed: the denial letter, my doctor's letter, and records [list].

If you keep the denial, please tell me how to ask for a fast
external review.

Sincerely,
[Signature]

Ask your doctor’s office to request a peer-to-peer

A short message often gets things moving:

“Hi, my prior authorization for [service] was denied on [date], reference [number]. Could Dr. [name] request a peer-to-peer review with the insurer before the window closes? I’m happy to send anything you need from me.”

How should a lab handle prior authorization problems for lab tests?

A lab handles a prior authorization denied lab test best by catching the requirement before the test runs. Check the payer’s list at intake. Send the ordering office a ready-to-sign request. Hold the claim until approval is on file. Many plans let only the ordering provider request approval.

This is the core problem for an independent lab. The lab bills the claim, but it often cannot ask for the approval itself. UnitedHealthcare’s genetic and molecular testing FAQ says it plainly. If a test needs prior authorization, the ordering care provider must submit it. The lab may only submit advance notification for tests that need notice.

Advance notification is a heads-up to the plan with no clinical review. Prior authorization needs the plan’s approval based on medical policy. Know which one your test needs before you call the office.

  1. Screen at intake. Match each CPT code to the payer’s lab prior auth list before the specimen is tested.
  2. Make the office’s job small. Send a one-page request with the CPT codes, units, diagnosis codes, and the payer’s medical policy name.
  3. Put it in writing. Your client service agreement should say who requests prior authorization and how fast.
  4. Match the claim to the approval. UnitedHealthcare tells billing labs to confirm the CPT codes and units match the approval before billing.
  5. Track repeat offenders. Report missing approvals by ordering office each month and review them with each client.

If a claim still denies with CO-197, ask the payer whether it allows a late review. Policies differ, so get the answer in writing. If units were short, see the CO-198 guide. Under CMS-0057-F, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid plans must decide standard requests within 7 calendar days.

In lab billing work, I have seen approval rates climb once the lab sent offices a filled-in request instead of a reminder to “get the auth.”

Is Emblem Health rejecting CPT 20611 for no prior authorization?

Emblem Health may reject CPT 20611 for no prior authorization when the member is on the NYCE PPO plan. That plan has its own list, separate from EmblemHealth’s HIP and GHI list. It names pain management and joint procedures as services that may need approval. Check the code at nyceppo.com.

CPT 20611 is arthrocentesis, aspiration, or injection of a major joint or bursa with ultrasound guidance, with a permanent record and report. Think knee, shoulder, or hip injections done under ultrasound.

We searched EmblemHealth’s enterprise preauthorization list, updated October 16, 2026. It covers HIP and GHI non-city members, and 20611 is not listed there. The NYCE PPO list is for New York City employees and is run with UnitedHealthcare. It is category-based, so a code search on its portal gives the real answer.

  • Check the member card. NYCE PPO members follow the NYCE PPO rules.
  • Search 20611 with the diagnosis and place of service on nyceppo.com, or call the number on the card.
  • If the injection drug needs its own approval, such as a hyaluronan, request both.

3-step checklist for lab and office prior auth

  1. Check the payer’s prior auth list by CPT code and plan before the service.
  2. Send the ordering office a filled-in request, and agree in writing who submits it.
  3. Bill only codes and units that match the approval, and log every missing approval by client.

Lab and NYCE PPO sections added 11 November 2026. Sources: UnitedHealthcare genetic and molecular lab testing prior authorization FAQ, EmblemHealth preauthorization list (updated October 16, 2026) and NYCE PPO services requiring prior authorization.

Read about the author, or contact us with a lab billing question. See our editorial policy.

FAQ

Can I still get the service while the prior authorization is denied?

You can, but you may have to pay for it. If you go ahead without approval, the claim may deny with CO-197. Ask the provider for a written cost estimate and whether they’ll wait for the appeal.

What is a peer-to-peer review?

It’s a phone call between your doctor and the insurer’s reviewer about the denial. Not every insurer offers one. Many set a short window, so the office should ask fast.

How fast must my insurer decide an urgent appeal?

Employer plans must decide urgent appeals within 72 hours. Since 2026, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP plans must make fast prior auth decisions within 72 hours under CMS-0057-F.

Should we resubmit or appeal?

If the denial says records were missing, resending a full request is often faster. If the reviewer disagreed with your doctor, a peer-to-peer call or an appeal is usually better.

Do prior authorization appeals actually work?

Often, yes. KFF looked at 2024 Medicare Advantage data. It found 80.7% of appealed prior auth denials were partly or fully overturned. Only 11.5% of denials were appealed.

Who requests prior authorization for a lab test?

Usually the ordering provider. Many plans, including UnitedHealthcare for genetic and molecular tests, accept prior authorization requests only from the ordering care provider. The lab can screen orders, send the office a ready request, and hold the claim until approval is on file.

Disclaimer: This article is educational and is not legal or medical advice. Prior auth rules and appeal rights depend on your plan and state. Ask your doctor if care can safely wait. Check your plan papers and each linked source, since rules change.

Written by Manikandan, RCM specialist at Medical Billing 101.

Sources

  1. eCFR, 29 CFR 2560.503-1, Claims procedure, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  2. eCFR, 42 CFR 422.568, Standard timeframes for organization determinations, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  3. CMS, Interoperability and Prior Authorization Final Rule (CMS-0057-F), retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  4. KFF, Medicare Advantage Insurers Made Nearly 53 Million Prior Authorization Determinations in 2024, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.
  5. X12, Claim Adjustment Reason Codes, retrieved 4 Oct 2026.

See also: Claim Denial Statistics 2026: 2025 prior authorization denial rates and how often appeals overturn them.

Related denial codes

Browse all denial codes (CARC, RARC and group codes)

Manikandan J

Written by

Manikandan J

CPC (AAPC), CRCR (HFMA)

Manikandan J is a CPC (AAPC) and CRCR (HFMA) certified medical billing professional with billing and RCM experience at athenahealth, Omega Healthcare, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Access Healthcare. He writes Medical Billing 101's guides on denial codes, appeals and patient billing help for US billers, providers and insured patients.

10+ years in US revenue cycle management. How we fact-check · LinkedIn profile

More about the author →